An Ethereum fraud case involving an alleged $25 million cryptocurrency theft has ended with the acquittal of brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno. US District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that prosecutors failed to prove the material misrepresentations needed to support the wire fraud and related charges.

The decision follows a mistrial a year earlier, when jurors could not agree on a verdict. Prosecutors had accused the former Massachusetts Institute of Technology students of manipulating Ethereum transaction processing to obtain approximately $25 million in around 12 seconds.

Judge finds the evidence insufficient for conviction

Clarke focused her ruling on whether the trial evidence could support convictions under the charges prosecutors brought. Even when viewing that evidence in the government’s favour, she concluded that prosecutors had not established the required material misrepresentations. Consequently, she granted the brothers’ motion and entered judgments of acquittal.

The judge also distinguished that legal question from a broader assessment of the brothers’ behaviour. Her decision did not determine whether their conduct was moral or whether it could have violated offences outside the case. Instead, it addressed the government’s failure to prove the charges before the court.

Authorities arrested the brothers in Boston and New York in May 2024 on wire fraud and money laundering charges. They faced potential prison sentences of up to 20 years on each count if convicted. However, the earlier jury deadlock left those allegations unresolved until the subsequent acquittal.

Prosecutors alleged manipulation of pending transactions

The Ethereum fraud case centred on a vulnerability in MEV-Boost relay software, which operates within Ethereum’s transaction-processing infrastructure. Prosecutors alleged that the brothers exploited the flaw to access the contents of a proposed transaction block before the relay should have released them.

According to the indictment, the brothers began preparing in December 2022 by studying traders’ behaviour. They allegedly introduced bait transactions to identify targets and then used the prematurely disclosed information to rearrange the proposed block for their own benefit.

Prosecutors said this sequence diverted approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency from the targeted traders. They also alleged that the brothers refused requests to return the funds. Those claims formed part of the prosecution’s account, but the court ultimately found its evidence insufficient to sustain the charged offences.

Alleged concealment formed part of the prosecution

The government also accused the brothers of establishing shell companies and using multiple cryptocurrency addresses and overseas exchanges. After the transactions, they allegedly moved the assets through further transfers to obscure their source and ownership. Prosecutors presented these actions as part of an effort to conceal the scheme.

In addition, investigators cited online searches concerning the exploit, concealment and exchanges with limited identity checks. The prosecution also referred to the brothers consulting lawyers with cryptocurrency and extradition expertise. Nevertheless, those surrounding circumstances did not resolve the evidentiary gap identified by Clarke.

The acquittal therefore turns on what prosecutors needed to establish in this specific Ethereum fraud case. The alleged technical manipulation and movement of funds did not, in the judge’s assessment, prove the material misrepresentations necessary for the convictions sought.


0 responses to “Ethereum fraud case ends in acquittal for brothers”